Expensive lens - still soft images!?


posted on 29th of july, 2010

Recently I have started to notice that we get an increasing number of product and people shots that are NOT out of focus, but are kind of soft anyway. As the review tool shows conveniently the EXIF of the photograph, a correlation started to emerge. Namely, the correlation between the aperture and softness of the image.

Now, most of you would think that - yes, but of course, the wider the aperture the softer the image and the shallower given depth of field. Right you are, but interestingly the same is true if you approach the other end of the possible aperture values.

How is this possible? Isn't it so, that the bigger "f-number" I have, the deeper DOF I achieve?

Correct. But in addition to depth of field, other characteristics come into play. So far so, that I say the DOF does not play a role in the sharpness of an image other than it just defines the spatial amount of image that is in focus. Extrapolating from this, the image can theoretically be "in focus", but it can still be unsharp if the quality of the lens itself is low - starting to get the picture?

One of these aperture characteristics has a nickname "sweet spot". This sweet spot moves around a bit from lens to lens, and without going too technical, depends upon the arrangement and groups of small lenses inside the housing.

Well, how to determine the sweet spot of your particular lens then?

There are several ways to do that, depending on your commitment and technical understanding. There are trial-and-error methods on one hand, and there are MTF charts, Nyquist frequencies and what not, at the other.

The rule of thumb, not the absolute truth, is that the lens is at its sharpest, from EDGE-TO-EDGE at apertures of some 3-4 f-stops smaller than the widest maximum. (Now, take note of this edge-to-edge, since the majority of "Poor optical performance" reject reason is for blurry edges!)

If you would like to understand what on earth the aperture is, I found an excellent blog already posted here on Dreamstime - thanks, Brad Calkin for taking the time to explain all this in layman's terms!

You can of course Google the "sweet spot of a lens", but in my quest I found one that gets you started:
Finding the sweet spot ยป

Since I am a Nikon-guy, I will post a few shortcuts to the MTF charts of most popular Nikon lenses:
Nikkor 50mm/f1.4
Nikkor 18-55mm/f3.5-5.6 VR (kit lens)
Nikkor 80-200mm/f2.8 VR



What you conclude from these charts (move the zoom and aperture sliders around at the bottom), is that
LENS SHARPNESS GENERALLY DROPS UP TO 50% WHEN STOPPED DOWN TO THE SMALLEST APERTURE!.



Next time you shoot an object in your light-tent, take a few samples to see if you really need that f32 or is just as well in DOF with f8-f11? It certainly will be SHARPER at the latter settings. If you MUST use those extreme aperture (shooting macro or the object is long on the axis of shooting) you have to sharpen the image afterwards in photoshop.

What we, reviewers, hate most is a professional looking and nicely composed image that is visibly soft at 100% :)

You can easily pick other makes and models from the huge database of the Dpreview specialists. To my knowledge it is the most respected independent photography equipment review site. Of course, Canon, Sigma, Tokina, etc are all covered so chances are that you'll find the lens review you are looking for.

Comments (11)

Posted by Mariusgradinaru on August 05, 2010
thank you for sharing :) love it
Posted by Manix43 on July 30, 2010
Incredible, would never have known otherwise. time to go spend a few hours playing with my lenses.
Posted by Rosedarc on July 29, 2010
Very interesting, I had noticed his problem with some of my images and a beautiful new lens I've got. I was wondering if this could be the reason or if it had to do with my tripod... I'll investigate a bit further
Posted by Dmccale on July 29, 2010
thanks for sharing.I love learning all I can.
Posted by Adeliepenguin on July 29, 2010
Very interesting! Since I am a Nikon user, I am definitely going to check out those links. I also run into the balancing act of lens sharpness vs depth of field, and I have a couple lenses I have decided not to use for stock work because I have had too many difficulties:)
Posted by Bradcalkins on July 29, 2010
Indeed, diffraction starts to limit your sharpness and it may be a trade off between depth of field and sharpness. Assuming that a small aperture is best may be in part due to the Sunny-16 'rule'. I wrote a blog about that assumption, too: Need a new rule? :)
Posted by smartview27 on July 29, 2010
I agree!
Posted by Petarneychev on July 29, 2010
Couldn't agree more!

As a note to all macro-lovers or others who are trying to achieve the maximum possible depth of field - read a bit about Focus Stacking techniques (if you're not familiar with them already) and put them to use. The results are superb and well worth the effort.
Posted by Egomezta on July 29, 2010
Thanks for sharing this info.... Sometimes we believe in the theory but it is more important to get to know your equipment too.
Posted by Cristalloid on July 29, 2010
The smaller the opening of the aperture (or the higher the aperture-number) the bigger the optical refraction on the aperture blades. And that is what makes an image soft, That`s the simple truth. Pure physics.
Posted by Yuritz on July 29, 2010
really an intresting blog,thanks for sharing your experience and the links!



Comments (11)

This article has been read 2679 times. 19 readers have found this article useful.
Photo credits: , Elopaint, Ryan Jorgensen, Kev303, Madartists, Yang Yu.

About me

(Demonike)
Peetri Alev, EE

Blogs Exclusive user
Archive
2011
December (1)
January (1)
2010
2008

Stock Photography that BLOGS!

Interact, make friends, share tips and techniques, have fun. Dreamstime wants your ideas and thoughts whether you are a photographer, designer or regular user. Create a blog to tell your story, promote favorite images and photographers, post tutorials or simply exchange opinions with your with fellow dreamstimers.

Don't forget words and pictures go great together so make sure you choose some Dreamstime favorite pics to brighten your article. For inspiration, check out the hottest or the most useful blogs on the left.

Create a blog to tell your story, promote favorite stock images and photographers

Create your blog

My favorite articles

    None

More favorite articles

Related image searches

lens aperture softness sweet spot

Sweet related stock images