Dealing with the sky in landscapes


posted on 25th of july, 2012

When photographing landscapes with big portions of the image being the sky, correct exposure is not trivial. Usually the sky is much brighter than the rest of the image. If leaving the camera on automatic exposure, what usually happens is the land gets a correct exposure but the sky is overexposed and shows white in the photo. A white sky is dull.
How to compensate for this? One way is to use HDR technique, with multiple exposures and combining them automatically or manually through Photoshop. It is a lot of work and it does not succeed always due to wind moving the trees, waves etc. Best results are when everything is dead still.
I have a simpler technique, one needs a camera with a good dynamic range. Any modern DSLR is OK. I underexpose the photo by approx 1 stop. This way the sky does not loose the information. It is more correctly exposed while the rest of the photo is underexposed and turns out dark. It is easier through post-processing to fix an underexposed image by adding more brightness than the other way around, darkening overexposed parts. This is what I do for a quick fix of the exposure.

In Photoshop
1. Copy the original Background layer.
2. On the Copied Layer Increase brightness until the land is properly exposed. (sky becomes overexposed but that's OK)
3. Add a mask layer to the background copy.
4. Create a gradient on the mask layer so that the sky image comes mostly from the background (original) while the land comes from the brightened background Copy.
Using the gradient will seamlessly make the transition between the two layers and the resulting image is better exposed

Comments (12)

Posted by Dprogers on August 03, 2012
Lightroom has a good graduated filter capability, with the advantage of changing the angle and steps of graduation.
Posted by Androniques on July 26, 2012
Yep, it may sometimes be a little awkward to play with real filters in the field, e.g. when it's windy. Recently I found that software gradient filters can also be applied during raw post-processing, which produces much less noise. Btw, I also like using masks and blended layers. :)
Posted by Gmargittai on July 26, 2012
Thanks for all the comments,
Indeed there are different methods of achieving this. The ND filter has been invented just for this purpose but forgive me saying is old technology. It belongs to film cameras although no doubt it works. With Photoshop one can achieve a much more precise tuning. And of course nothing beats bracketing your shot and combining the images. For best results with this a tripod is essential, but one can argue that for landscapes tripod is essential anyway.
I like playing with masks. :)
Posted by Mike2focus on July 25, 2012
Andromantic makes a very good point. If you have to lighten the areas that are too dark in post production, noise will be exposed. It can be an issue. That's why bracketing capabilities are so important to have on your camera. Set up a five exposure bracket and then select the best shot of the sky and mask in the best shot of the land. This way you're getting the correct exposure for both, but you don't have to push anything in post production that will expose any noise!

That being said... I agree with Nigelspiers, too. Slapping on a filter that is appropriate for the situation would be the easiest way :-)
Posted by Nigelspiers on July 25, 2012
Hi Gavril,

I agree - white skies spoil a photo and it almost drove me mad until I bought a Hoya circular polaroid filter for $85. Bingo! - no more white skies. I now leave this filter on for every outdoor photo I take because it increases the overall color saturation and produces fabulously detailed skies. I now just need to adjust the exposure on each shot.
Posted by Androniques on July 25, 2012
Hi Gavril,

Thanks for a nicely put method. :)
I used to do exactly as you describe (apart from choosing the underexposure degree depending on the relative top/bottom brightness difference, which is obvious). However, often when I needed to step down that much, 1 stop or more, the brightening step for the lower non-sky part would bring up some of the hidden noise in those darkish underexposed areas. It was mostly alright for myself and my friends, but when I started uploading in microstock, the noise level appeared to be unacceptable, resulting in refusals. Eventually I gave up this method, and now most often use ND and CP filters.

Please, do not take my remark as criticism. Maybe I am missing something that you did not mention. Could you comment on this noise issue. Thanks in advance. Great landscapes, btw!
Posted by Blueiris07 on July 25, 2012
I have not as yet tried your technique. I usually make a levels adjustment then use the history brush to ring back the exposure in areas that do not need the adjustment. I have had good luck doing this. Is there a reason to expect better results using your technique?
Posted by Halilin on July 25, 2012
thanks...
Posted by Digitalexpressionimages on July 25, 2012
Or you could pick up a graduated neutral density filter. Easier and works very well in most situations.
Posted by Chanevy on July 25, 2012
Thank you! Very concise and very helpful.
Posted by Physi28 on July 25, 2012
thanks for the tutorial, well explained!
Posted by FabioConcetta on July 25, 2012
Small tutorial, but very useful and well explained, congratulations!



Comments (12)

This article has been read 1097 times. 8 readers have found this article useful.
Photo credits: Gavril Margittai.

About me

(Gmargittai)
San Jose, US

Blogs Exclusive user
Archive
2014
September (1)
July (1)
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009

Stock Photography that BLOGS!

Interact, make friends, share tips and techniques, have fun. Dreamstime wants your ideas and thoughts whether you are a photographer, designer or regular user. Create a blog to tell your story, promote favorite images and photographers, post tutorials or simply exchange opinions with your with fellow dreamstimers.

Don't forget words and pictures go great together so make sure you choose some Dreamstime favorite pics to brighten your article. For inspiration, check out the hottest or the most useful blogs on the left.

Create a blog to tell your story, promote favorite stock images and photographers

Create your blog

My favorite articles

    None

More favorite articles

Related image searches

masking photoshop landscape exposure sky

Photoshop related stock images